Jackson’s criticisms were shared by "anti-bank, hard money agrarians" as well as eastern financial interests, especially in New York City, who resented the central bank's restrictions on easy credit. They alleged that this was unfair to farmers and allowed creditors to profit without creating tangible wealth, while a creditor would argue that he was performing a service and was entitled to profit from it. , The enemies of the Bank were shocked and outraged by both speeches.  They did however assure Biddle that Jackson would not veto the bill so close to the 1832 election. Removal of Deposits Shortly after the election, the war escalated. Jacksonian Democrats pointed to the fact that Senators were beholden to the state legislatures that selected them; the Whigs pointing out that the chief executive had been chosen by electors, and not by popular vote. He went on to argue that if such an institution was truly necessary for the United States, its charter should be revised to avoid constitutional objections. Perhaps you pictured two banks competing against one another for customers or business Consequently, Jackson set out to destroy the Bank. The Treasury Department maintained normal working relations with Biddle, whom Jackson reappointed as a government director of the Bank. At least partially, this was a reasonable response to several factors that threatened the Bank's resources and continued profitability. In the words of historian Bray Hammond, "This was a very large 'if,' and the secretary came to realize it. Jackson vetoed the bill, beginning the long struggle which has become known as "The Bank War."  The B.U.S. Most Old Republicans had supported Crawford in 1824.  Economic planning at the federal level was deemed necessary by Republican nationalists to promote expansion and encourage private enterprise.  When a New York delegation visited him to complain about problems being faced by the state's merchants, Jackson responded saying: Go to Nicholas Biddle. The directors replied that they could not produce these books because they were not in the Bank's possession.  However, since lending was tied directly to the amount of gold and silver that banks stored in their vaults, the influx of precious metals into the United States encouraged American banks to print more paper money. The federal government purchased a fifth of the Bank's stock, appointed a fifth of its directors, and deposited its funds in the Bank. , Clay and Massachusetts Senator Daniel Webster warned Americans that if Jackson won reelection, he would abolish the Bank. There, he announced that the Bank would raise interest rates in the coming months in order to stockpile the Bank's monetary reserves. However, Harrison died after only a month in office, and his successor, John Tyler, vetoed two bills to reestablish the Bank. These were to be used only to counteract any hostile behavior from the B.U.S. " Support for this "national system of money and finance" grew with the post-war economy and land boom, uniting the interests of eastern financiers with southern and western Republican nationalists. When Jackson entered the White House in March 1829, dismantling the Bank was not part of his reform agenda. Jackson’s Bank War was in phase two. He blamed Jackson for the loss of his job. Meanwhile, Biddle wrote to Webster successfully urging the Senate not to support Stevenson as minister. In return, McLane asked that Jackson not mention the Bank in his annual address to Congress. , The Bank War far from settled the status of banking in the United States. Outcome State banks then made an increasing amount of paper money, which resulted in the overall value being worth less.  The address signaled to pro-B.U.S.  Biddle carefully explored his options for persuading Jackson to support recharter. Jacksonians from pursuing their attack on the B.U.S.  The federal government earned an average of about $2 million each year from land sales in the 1820s. There was a strong movement to increase the power of the federal government. If Biddle presented any of the state banks with notes and demanded specie as payment, the banks could present him with the drafts to remove the deposits from the Bank and protect their liquidity.  This managed to keep the Philadelphia branch operating at a price of nearly $6 million. Shortly after, the Globe announced that the President intended to stand for reelection. McLane and Lewis, however, told Biddle that the chances of recharter would be greater if he waited until after the election of 1832. The Bank War was a bitter and personal dispute between Jackson and his enemies. The hopes of the bank's supporters to turn the veto in a winning campaign …  The Second Bank of the United States was given considerable powers and privileges under its charter. , In 1828, Jackson ran again. Benton called the statement an "atrocious calumny". The unconfirmed cabinet members, appointed during a congressional recess, consisted of McLane for Secretary of State, Benjamin F. Butler for Attorney General, and Taney for Secretary of the Treasury. Andrew Jackson's Presidency Bank War and IRA Uploaded by prazzperkasa on Dec 04, 2011. Thomas Cadwalader, a fellow B.U.S.  With the crisis over, Jackson could turn his attention back to the Bank.  To that end, Clay helped introduce recharter bills in both the House and Senate. In case the B.U.S. Soon afterward, Jackson signed the Specie Circular, an executive order mandating that sales of public lands in parcels over 320 acres be paid for only in gold and silver coin. In 1829 and again in 1830 Jackson made clear his constitutional objections and personal antagonism toward the bank.  Farmers and planters suffered from price deflation and debt-default spirals. , Under the Bank charter terms of 1816, the U.S. Secretary of the Treasury was empowered, with Congress, to make all decisions regarding the federal deposits. Distinctions in society will always exist under every just government. As a result, the prices of American goods abroad collapsed. Andrew Jackson. His “war” on the banking industry was mostly bark instead of bite, as he withdrew funds from the national bank to deposit them in state and local banks. He refutes the idea that the collapse of the Bank was responsible for the Panic of 1837, which he describes as "a world-wide economic collapse", but concedes that it "may have exacerbated" the crisis. Inflation caused during the Revolutionary War by printing enormous amounts of paper money added to the distrust, and opposition to it was a major reason for Hamilton's difficulties in securing the charter of the First Bank of the United States.  They claimed that by lending money in large amounts to wealthy well-connected speculators, it restricted the possibility for an economic boom that would benefit all classes of citizens. Although the President harbored an antipathy toward all banks, several members of his initial cabinet advised a cautious approach when it came to the B.U.S. Nearly all politicians joined the Republican Party, founded by Jefferson.  The President replaced McLane with William J. Duane, a reliable opponent of the Bank from Pennsylvania.  The resulting drop in the price of cotton precipitated much of the damage of the financial panic. It used loans and "retainer's fees", such as with Webster, to influence congressmen.  The Globe refrained from openly attacking Secretary McLane, but in lieu of this, reprinted hostile essays from anti-Bank periodicals.  The practical implications of the veto were enormous.  Hammond, in his Banks and Politics in America from the Revolution to the Civil War, renews the criticism of Schlesinger.  On his first day at his post, Secretary Duane was informed by Kendall, who was in name his subordinate in the Treasury Department, that Duane would be expected to defer to the President on the matter of the deposits. Andrew Jackson.  Robert V. Remini believes that the Bank had "too much power, which it was obviously using in politics. newspaper editors, Jackson secured an overwhelming election victory. He believed it concentrated too much economic power in the hands of a small monied elite beyond the public’s control.  After the release of these reports, Biddle went to the Bank's board to ask for permission to use some of the Bank's funds for printing and dissemination. , In spite of Jackson's address, no clear policy towards the Bank emerged from the White House.  To defuse a potentially explosive political conflict, some Jacksonians encouraged Biddle to select candidates from both parties to serve as B.U.S.  In response, the Democratic-controlled House conducted an inquiry, submitting a divided committee report (4–3) that declared the deposits perfectly safe. Clay responded by sarcastically alluding to a brawl that had taken place between Thomas Benton and his brother Jesse against Andrew Jackson in 1813. , These reforms required a rapprochement between Jackson and Biddle on the matter of recharter, with McLane and Livingston acting as liaisons.  The plan was approved, and a bipartisan committee was sent to Philadelphia to look into the matters. Jackson’s decisive reelection in 1832 was once interpreted as a sign of popular agreement with the Democratic interpretation…. He praises the Bank and Biddle's conduct, claiming that Jackson's war on it created a periodic of economic instability that would not be remedied until the creation of the Federal Reserve in 1913.  In 1836, President Jackson signed the Deposit and Distribution Act, which transferred funds from the Treasury Department’s budget surplus into various deposit banks located in the interior of the country. A delay would obviate these risks.  The objective had been reached in part through Jackson's reforms aimed at eliminating the misuse of funds, and through the veto of legislation he deemed extravagant. The Bank War does not warrant a 500 page tome, but this book is just long enough to provide sufficient depth.  He secretly worked with Biddle to create a reform package.  According to historian Robert V. Remini, the Bank exercised "full control of credit and currency facilities of the nation and adding to their strength and soundness". Jackson viewed the issue as a political liability—recharter would easily pass both Houses with simple majorities—and as such, would confront him with the dilemma of approving or disapproving the legislation ahead of his reelection. To replace Taney, Jackson nominated Woodbury, who, despite the fact that he also supported removal, was confirmed unanimously on June 29. Second, I will talk about the Presidential election of 1824, 1828, and 1832. Indeed, Jackson had predicted in his first annual message of 1829 that the Bank's stockholders would submit an early application to Congress. The liquidation of government stock would necessitate substantial changes to the Bank's charter, which Jackson supported. Then there was the removal of the public deposits, congressional testimony indicating that the Jacksonians had attempted to sabotage the Bank's public image and solvency by manufacturing bank runs at branch offices in Kentucky, the responsibility of maintaining a uniform currency, the administration's goal of retiring the public debt in a short period, bad harvests, and expectations that the Bank would continue to lend to commercial houses and return dividends to stockholders. T he Pet Banks History for kids: The State Banks The Second Bank of the United States, the National Bank was responsible for only 20% of the currency supply - the state banks accounted for the rest.  The chaos of the war had, according to some, "demonstrated the absolute necessity of a national banking system". , The final bill sent to Jackson's desk contained modifications of the Bank's original charter that were intended to assuage many of the President's objections.  The Jacksonian press, disappointed by the president’s subdued and conciliatory tone towards the Bank, launched fresh and provocative assaults on the institution. The Bank War was a political struggle that developed over the issue of rechartering the Second Bank of the United States (B.U.S.)  Banks have to lend more money than they take in. This left open the possibility that he could stymie the renewal of the Bank's charter should he win a second term. , Biddle traveled to Washington, D.C. to personally conduct the final push for recharter. He was subsequently sued for nearly $25 million and acquitted on charges of criminal conspiracy, but remained heavily involved in lawsuits until the end of his life. Jackson's veto and the decreasing likelihood of obtaining a new federal charter meant that the Bank would soon have to wind up its affairs. , The Bank War has proven to be a controversial subject in the scholarly community long after it took place.  During the final phase of the 1832 election campaign, Kendall and Blair had convinced Jackson that the transfer of the federal deposits—20% of the Bank's capital—into private banks friendly to the administration would be prudent. The board, which was composed of Biddle and like-minded colleagues, agreed.  Jackson himself, though naturally averse to the Bank, had recommended the establishment of a branch in Pensacola. , Whigs and Democrats blamed each other for the crisis. , Kendall and Taney began to seek cooperative state banks which would receive the government deposits.  194 of the 729 banks with charters closed their doors.  The Independent Treasury was recreated under the Polk presidency in 1846. This would lead to lenders demanding that the banks take back their devalued paper in exchange for specie, as well as debtors trying to pay off loans with the same deflated currency, seriously disrupting the economy. , Too late, Clay "realized the impasse into which he had maneuvered himself, and made every effort to override the veto". , The executive branch, Jackson averred, when acting in the interests of the American people, was not bound to defer to the decisions of the Supreme Court, nor to comply with legislation passed by Congress. Lewis then asked what he would do if Congress overrode his veto. " Not long after, it was announced in the Globe that Jackson would receive no more delegations to converse with him about money. To them, the Bank symbolized corruption while threatening liberty. It tried to ensure steady growth by forcing state-chartered banks to keep specie reserves.  One of the most "popular and effective documents in American political history", Jackson outlined a major readjustment to the relative powers of the government branches. , President Madison and Treasury Secretary Albert Gallatin supported recharter of the First Bank in 1811. The first Coinage Act was passed in 1792 and established a 15 to 1 ratio for gold to silver coins. He returned unsigned, with his objections, a bill that extended the charter of the Second Bank of the United States, due to expire in 1836, for another fifteen years. Jackson had to submit all three nominations at once, and so he delayed submitting them until the last week of the Senate session on June 23.  He accused Jackson of ignorance on financial matters..  Southern planters bought large amounts of public land and produced more cotton to try to pay off their debts. Clay in 1834 pushed a resolution through the Senate censuring Jackson for removing the deposits. The national bank was observed by Jackson to jeopardize economic stability and served as a monopoly on country’s currency. Educators and Parents/Guardians of K-12 students may now register FREE for full website access. The proposals included some limited reforms by placing restrictions on the Bank's powers to own real estate and create new branches, give Congress the ability to prevent the Bank from issuing small notes, and allow the president to appoint one director to each branch of the Bank.  Andrew Jackson, previously a major general in the United States Army and former territorial governor of Florida, sympathized with these concerns, privately blaming the Bank for causing the Panic by contracting credit. Jacksonians. Jackson was enraged by this so-called "corrupt bargain" to subvert the will of the people.  Jackson subsequently shifted both pro-Bank cabinet members to other posts: McLane to the Department of State, and Livingston to Europe, as U.S. Minister to France. The economy did extremely well during Jackson's time as president, but his economic policies, including his war against the Bank, are sometimes blamed for contributing to the Panic of 1837. " In 1820, John Tyler of Virginia wrote that "if Congress can incorporate a bank, it might emancipate a slave". It enjoyed enormous political and financial power, and there were no practical limits on what Biddle could do.  He believed that the Bank was unconstitutional and that the Supreme Court, which had declared it constitutional, did not have the power to do so without the "acquiesence of the people and the states". It was undervalued and thus rarely circulated. He resigned immediately. Taney was rejected by a vote of 28–18. In the full enjoyment of the gifts of Heaven and the fruits of superior industry, economy, and virtue, every man is equally entitled to protection by law; but when the laws undertake to add to these natural and just advantages artificial distinctions, to grant titles, gratuities, and exclusive privileges, to make the rich richer and the potent more powerful, the humble members of society-the farmers, mechanics, and laborers-who have neither the time nor the means of securing like favors to themselves, have a right to complain of the injustice of their Government.  Another result of the reports was that the Bank's stock rose following the drop that it experienced from Jackson's remarks. Biddle has all the money. On their advice, Biddle applied for a new charter even though the old charter did not expire until 1836.  Including when taking into account the recession engineered by Biddle, the economy expanded at an unprecedented rate of 6.6% per year from 1830 to 1837.